Hiking Team: Dave Miller
Date: August 7, 2026
Good urban legends attract me, and this is a good one. This .3-mile hike near Mt. Davis, the highest point in Pennsylvania, kept me alert for black bears and wild turkeys. It culminated at a bunch of large rocks with dangerous crevices and a snaky path below winding through them. This isolated, strange area gave me the creeps. Two bizarre mysteries are associated with this area.
Henry Baughman had two sons and an extremely bad temper. One day in the 1850’s while looking for lost cows, Henry got mad at his son August and clubbed him with a stick. Thinking he was dead, Henry hid the body in the rocks with the intention of returning later and burying him. Returning later, the body had disappeared. Baughman was tried and convicted of second-degree murder based on his other son’s testimony. August’s body was never found.
A second urban legend is that in 1830, ten-year-old Lydia Shultz was sent to look for lost cows. She never came home. Search parties failed to find her. Months later she was discovered and had turned so wild that she hid from searchers. She had survived by eating wild plants and berries. She returned to civilization and allegedly lived to the age of 25.
















































